“The sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath.” Mark 2:27
On a friend’s recommendation, I picked up the book Christian Education, written by a Catholic priest and published in 1944. Within the first three pages, the critical understanding of the purpose of education practically jumped off the page. Fr. Edward Leen, C.S.Sp., offers this definition for education:
“To the Christian, ‘education’ is that culture of the mind, the will, and the emotions, which, whilst adapting a man for the exercise of a particular calling, disposes him to achieve an excellent personal and social life within the framework of that calling. The object of education is nothing short of human happiness.”i
This concept, aptly captured by Classical Conversations as “to know God and make Him known,” offers a keen insight into the overarching objective of education. Another way to understand Leen’s point of “human happiness” is to grow fully self-aware of who we are in the image and likeness of God, the imago Dei. This definition gave me pause and prompted reflection on my educational experience, leading me to consider the ultimate objective of education. Where is the authority to educate derived? What role should a government have in education? These questions were addressed in previous articles in this series, but they raise a critical point: Does government education policy seek to preserve institutions or to educate children?
Identifying the objective of government education policy requires first determining the government’s interest in an educated population. Between 1642 and 1648, the Massachusetts Bay Colony passed three laws that are commonly considered the initial steps leading to compulsory public education in the United States. These three laws addressed three key principles: first, they shifted supervision for education from the clergy to the boards of government; second, they required each town to cover the expenses for hiring teachers and imposed a fine on those who did not obey; and third, they required parents to ensure their children could read and write.ii Proponents of compulsory education often cite these laws as early precedents for state-enforced, publicly funded, and government-managed education. The Massachusetts laws established minimum expectations; children were to learn to read, understand the colony’s laws, and receive religious instruction. Responsibility for accomplishing those ends remained principally with the families, masters, and local communities. The colony prescribed a minimum standard; it did not seek to construct a comprehensive system that dictated the entire educational process. Following the Massachusetts Bay Colony laws as a precedent, the government has a legitimate interest in an educated constituency. However, that interest does not confer primary authority upon the State to determine both the means and formation of the child.
Preserving Institutions?
In 1842, Horace Mann, the “father” of the modern compulsory education movement, gave an oration on July 4th in Boston, Massachusetts. He discussed the need for universal education to ensure universal political participation. He based his idea on the broad distribution of power, the dependency of a republican government on character, and the capacity for people to exercise that power.iii He called for institutional change to ensure an educated population where “universal education joined hands with universal suffrage. Mann called for binding universal education to the self-preservation of the established order, the constitutional republic. Was Mann calling to form children according to the freedom that comes with self-awareness, or to preserve the institutions of the Republic? The term “institution” has two primary definitions. It is an established system of values, rules, norms, and roles that shape human behavior.iv It is also an organized body created for a particular social or public purpose.v Taking into account the theme of Mann’s oration, which calls for the State to establish a universal education policy, the State has begun to move beyond the original minimum standard established by the Massachusetts Bay Colony. The State begins to decide the type of citizen produced. The question then shifts from one of safeguarding institutions to garnering and protecting the levers of authority. Was the objective of universal education a means to preserve the institution, or a tool for ensuring that authority to educate resides with the government? Mann’s speech may have resonated with a particular need, but it was still focused on preserving the Republic rather than fostering future generations of independent, free critical thinkers. The system of publicly directed education championed by Mann formed part of the intellectual inheritance of the educational establishment that followed. Teachers College, founded in 1887, became one of its most influential centers, later bringing together figures such as John Dewey and George Counts.
Controlling the Tools of Power
Both Dewey and Counts were instrumental in progressing their shared vision of reconstructing American society through public education in the early 20th century.vi By the time Dewey and Counts became leading influences in American education, compulsory schooling was already widespread; by 1918, every state had enacted a compulsory attendance law. Between 1897 and 1916, Dewey developed his idea that the purpose of education is to shape students’ emotions, minds, and direction. In his 1897 work “My Pedagogic Creed,” he expounds on education as a means of social reform, specifically insisting that the school is the primary vehicle driving it. He further elaborates on the importance of education in driving social reform in his 1916 work Democracy and Education, arguing that the common school is the tool for shaping the mental and emotional dispositions of individuals.vii George Counts amplifies Dewey’s message in Dare the School Build a New Social Order by calling on teachers to seek power and use the curriculum to shape social attitudes, ideals, and behavior.viii Counts further embraces social reconstruction and calls for a new version of the American destiny that is progressive in its thinking and direction.ix Social reconstruction drew heavily from socialist and Marxist thought, shifting the purpose of education from preparing citizens to sustain the existing republican order toward using schools as instruments for deliberately reshaping society.x Mann sought to preserve the Republic by educating its citizens; Dewey and Counts increasingly treated education as a means to reconstruct the society those citizens inhabited.
Looking out for the Children
Even if the Massachusetts Bay Colony did not intend to place the entire educational process under government control, its laws established that the government could set minimum educational standards. Mann expanded that principle by connecting universal education to the preservation of republican government. Dewey and Counts went further, arguing that education could shape social dispositions and reconstruct society. The question, therefore, becomes less about whether the government has an interest in an educated population and more about who possesses the authority to define the purpose and content of that education. If the legitimate government interest is simply an educated citizenry, then the government need not possess exclusive authority over the means by which citizens become educated.
Families, churches, private schools, tutors, apprenticeships, and other associations are equally capable of producing educated people. Yet compulsory education systems preserve something beyond access to instruction: they preserve the State’s authority to establish standards, determine acceptable educational outcomes, and define what constitutes legitimate education. This returns us to Leen’s original definition. If “the object of education is nothing short of human happiness,” then the institution must remain subordinate to the person it serves. The child cannot become merely the instrument through which an institution reproduces the social order it prefers. The role of government in education should focus solely on protecting the parents’ right to choose to educate their children. Education must be oriented toward growing in self-awareness through a relationship with the Lord rather than preservation of government authority. Since the inception of the first common school in 1837, government overreach has been the only common outcome. When preserving that authority becomes the objective, the institution ceases to serve education, and education begins to serve the State.”
Education, like the Sabbath, was made for the child, not the child for education.
i Edward Leen, Christian Education (Sheed & Ward, 1944; repr., Cluny Media, 2025).
ii David Carleton, “Old Deluder Satan Act of 1647 (1647),” Education, Free Speech Center, Middle Tennessee State University, January 1, 2009, https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/old-deluder-satan-act-of-1647/.
iii Horace Mann, “An Uneducated Ballot the Winding-Sheet of Liberty: The Existing Schools Inadequate to Support a Republican Government,” Oration, July 4, 1842.
iv Douglas North, Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance (Cambridge University Press, 1990).
v Oxford University Press, “Definition of Institution,” in Oxford English Dictionary (2026).
vi Joshua Pierson, “The Silent War,” in Woke and Weaponized: How Karl Marx Won the Battle for American Education and How We Can Win It Back (Classical Conversations Multimedia, Inc., 2025).
vii John Dewey, “My Pedagogic Creed,” The School Journal (New York) 54, no. 3 (1897): 77–80; John Dewey, The School and Society (University of Chicago Press, 1899), https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/53910; John Dewey, Democracy and Education: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Education (Free Press, 1997).
viii George Counts, Dare the School Build a New Social Order (John Day Company, 1932), https://brittlebooks.library.illinois.edu/brittlebooks_closed/Books2008-02/counge0001darsch/counge0001darsch.pdf.
ix Joshua Pierson, “The Silent War,” in Woke and Weaponized: How Karl Marx Won the Battle for American Education and How We Can Win It Back (Classical Conversations Multimedia, Inc., 2025). “Progressive” in this sense in the early 20th century meant “socialist” or “communist.” Both Dewey and Counts traveled abroad to the Soviet Union, and both expressed deep appreciation for the method and process of Soviet education. Both individuals sought to replicate the Soviet model in the US.
x Blogs 1–4 in this series explain the tools of social reconstruction, such as CASEL, which are considered part of a dogmatic pedagogy in public education in some states. For more information on the tools of communism applied to students in public school, see Appendix 2, “The Silent War,” by Joshua Pierson, DSS, in “Woke and Weaponized Education,” by Robert Bortins and Alex Newman.



