The holiday season is upon us! With it comes delicious food, theological reflections, and family gatherings during which we all try to sidestep touchy conversation topics like soldiers avoiding deadly land mines.
Isn’t the cliché that you should never talk about money, religion, or politics at the dinner table? This socially accepted strategy comes from a logical place. If hard conversations have been painful in the past, the natural response is to avoid them. What if the problem, however, is not what was being discussed, but how it was being discussed? Could this be an area in which we could improve our conversational skills? What if you could have healthy, productive, and loving conversations about things that matter to your family?
This article uses the classical tools to help you spark meaningful conversations with your family about the topic of education independence.
Grammar: What Is Education Independence?
- What do you think the purpose of education is?
- Who is responsible for education?
- Who should be allowed to shape the ideas a child is taught?
- If education is the responsibility of parents, should that responsibility include financial responsibility?
- What do you think a child gains when education happens inside the daily life of a family?
- What happens when the government decides what is taught, even when its intentions are good?
- What role does the government currently have in education?
Dialectic: Why Is Education Independence Important?
- What do you see as the biggest difference between private and public education?
- What differences between public and private education matter most to you?
- When a family chooses public or private school, what do you think they are really choosing?
- If your child is educated publicly or privately, how much say do you feel you have in what they learn?
- What would you want to be true about education for every child?
- When you think about who knows a child best, who comes to mind first?
- How would education change if it were built around a family’s goals instead of the state’s goals?
Rhetoric: How Does Education Independence Relate to Current Events?
- What is the difference between keeping more of what you own versus being given money from a public program?
- When government approves who can receive funds and how they can be used, how might that change the independence of the families and schools involved?
- What education policies has our state passed or debated recently?
- How do you think education policies affect families like ours?
- What do you think school choice supporters are hoping to improve?
- Do you worry the School Choice movement might negatively change education?
- What do you think a society looks like when families, not governments, lead in education?
- Where else have you seen people wrestle with a hard question together and come away better for it?
So, if you are tired of avoiding land mines through silence, there is a better way. It can start with a single question asked in love over a piece of pie. Pick a question from this list, listen well, and let truth do the heavy lifting, because a family that can wrestle with big ideas together is already practicing what it means to pursue independence.



